A Curious Question…
A recent hiker on the trails at Tryon Creek State Natural Area asked the park’s volunteer forester extraordinaire, Bruce Rottink:
“Is it true that Douglas-firs never lose their needles?”
Being the knowledgeable naturalist that he is, Bruce has given us the answers…enjoy!
Why is an evergreen, ever green?
By Bruce Rottink, Volunteer Nature Guide and Retired Research Forester
Tryon Creek State Natural Area supports an abundance of evergreens. Perhaps the most impressive are the massive Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii) trees. On a recent nature hike, an adult hiker asked me if it was true that Douglas-firs never lose their needles. Actually, Douglas-firs do lose their needles; it is just that they do it on a different schedule from the broadleaved trees like maple and alder.
To show how this works, I picked up the Douglas-fir branch in the photo below at Tryon Creek SNA after a windstorm. I cut off all the side branches to make it easier to see the needle retention pattern on this main branch. The orange ribbons mark the places on the branch where one year’s growth stops and the next year’s growth starts. Thus, in this picture, you can see branch segments that grew out in 6 consecutive years. The oldest part of the branch is on the right.
Okay, first things first; how can you tell the different year’s of branch growth?
On relatively young branches (up to about 5 years old) of many trees, it is easy to see the point at which one-year’s growth stopped and the next year’s growth started. Check out the ring around the branch below, it’s marking the end of one year’s shoot growth and the start of the next year’s. These rings are eventually obscured as the branch becomes thicker. In addition, a standard ring count on the cut end of a branch works too (I counted this branch myself, 6 rings = 6 years).
The youngest segment of the branch we find at the end, showing off its spiral brush of needles. All the needles were originally formed this past summer and are still present. At the tip of the branch, you can see the grayish-purple pointed bud that was scheduled to elongate next spring to produce the next year’s branch segment.
This branch segment shown below, has all of the needles originally formed and they are still on the branch.
On the branch segment below, almost all of the original needles have persisted on the tree, both on the upper and lower sides of the branch. However, a small number of needles have been lost.
Check out this branch segment below, many of the needles on the upper side of the branch have persisted, while only a few of the needles on the lower side of the branch (the bottom of the picture), still remain.
The age is really starting to show on this branch below, almost all the needles on the underside of the branch (the lower part of the picture), and many from the top side, have dropped off. However, many of the needles on the upper side of the branch persist. These needles have been alive for 5 growing seasons. Did you know? That when a needle falls off, it leaves a small scar on the branch. Can you spot the round bumps? (hint: they resemble pores on the branch)
The answer to the question from the curious hiker, lays at the beginning of our branch. Below you will see that all the needles have dropped off. No new needles will ever form on this branch. Thus, the answer is…FALSE to our original question,“Is it true that Douglas-firs never lose their needles?”